Work/Failure review // Topology optimization // FEA // Metal AM

It broke under my heel.
Now it is a branching aluminum part.

A printed heel guard keeps my boot off the chain on a 2001 Honda XR50. The first one snapped. I found the root cause, set up real loads for an adult rider, and let topology optimization find the load paths. That plastic part passed its fit check and is on the bike. Then I took the same load paths into metal: a twin-limb branching aluminum part, built from code, resized by FEA against eight load cases including crashes, printed in AlSi10Mg, painted to match the bike and bolted on.

XR50 chain guard, on the bike view
Bike
2001 Honda XR50, stock frame
Rider
180 to 220 lb adult
Material
AlSi10Mg, laser powder bed fusion, painted to match the bike
Load cases
8: five riding, three crash, all under yield (simulated)
Weight
About 3.8 oz, 109 g
Status
Aluminum part painted and on the bike
Real part, real photos

Out of the box, painted, bolted on

The painted aluminum chain guard mounted on the XR50, seen from the chain side
On the bike. The heel pad sits right where a boot lands, the chain runs underneath
Top view of the aluminum chain guard on the frame tab with safety-wired bolts
M8 drilled hex bolts, safety wired, no washers
Inboard view of the aluminum chain guard showing the twin-limb arms
Twin-limb arms from the inboard side
Straight out of the box. Raw AlSi10Mg, bead blasted, before paint
The painted aluminum chain guard held next to the plastic print it replaced
Aluminum next to the plastic part it replaced. Same load paths, different material

Where it stands

The part came back from the printer bead blasted, got painted to match the bike, holes reamed to size, and went on with safety-wired bolts. It is on the bike now and holding up. Ride results and the proof test numbers land here as they come in.

Chapter 2: metal AM

Same load paths, a part that grows like a tree

Rear quarter render of the aluminum XR50 chain guard with twin-limb branching arms
V11.1-AL: twin-limb branching arms and a branching faceplate. Render from the print file
1

Twin-limb branching arms

Every long load path is split into two limbs with cross links, like a tree branch. Each limb keeps one diameter along its length, so the part prints clean and the look stays consistent.

2

Branching faceplate

The heel pad is a recursive tree: four trunks from the center that fork twice on the way to the rim, with solid hubs where the arms land. It stops a boot heel with a fraction of the material of a solid plate.

3

Every member sized by FEA

A script maps the stress field back to each limb and resizes it against the allowable, then snaps the diameters to a few tiers. 12 g came off the previous version with the crash peaks held.

4

Built for the process

Bolt holes print undersize and get reamed. Mount and heel faces stay flat for support. M8 drilled hex bolts get safety wired, no washers. Bead blasted, then painted.

Heel face of the aluminum chain guard showing the branching faceplate
Heel face. Four trunks fork twice on the way to the rim
Underside of the aluminum chain guard showing the twin-limb arms
Underside. Each long arm is two limbs with cross links
Bolt side of the aluminum chain guard showing the clean mounting face
Bolt side. Flat mounting face, bosses bridged, bolts safety wired
Results (simulated)

Eight load cases, all under yield

Simulated stress on the heel face of the aluminum chain guard for six load cases
Heel face, von Mises stress. Riding cases on a 0 to 14.5 ksi scale, crash cases on 0 to 29 ksi. Linear FEA, 1 mm voxels

Pad toward the chain, peak stress, safety factor on yield

CasePadPeakSF
Heel push225 lbf into the pad0.008 in13.2 ksi2.0
Heel on outer edge180 lbf on the pad tip0.004 in7.8 ksi3.3
Heel and scrub forward157 lbf in, 90 lbf forward0.002 in8.7 ksi3.0
Heel and scrub back157 lbf in, 90 lbf back0.009 in13.6 ksi1.9
Chain slap67 lbf outward from the chain0.002 in out3.9 ksi6.6
Crash, tip-over450 lbf inboard on the pad tip0.004 in17.6 ksi1.5
Crash, slide forward337 lbf in, 225 lbf forward0.005 in22.9 ksi1.1
Crash, slide back337 lbf in, 225 lbf back0.009 in23.4 ksi1.1
  • Riding loads clear yield by 1.9x or better. Crash cases are one-time events and clear by 1.1x or better: a local spot may yield, the part stays on the bike.
  • The pad never moves more than 0.01 in toward the chain. The plastic part moved 0.05 in in its worst case, the original 0.22 in.
  • About 3.8 oz. Less than an ounce over the plastic part, in aluminum.

Linear static FEA on the final print mesh. Yield taken as 26 ksi for stress-relieved AlSi10Mg, to be confirmed on the vendor sheet. A heel-stand proof test on the first part is still to come.

Simulated stress on the aluminum chain guard at a 225 lbf heel push, bolt side and heel face
Heel push, 225 lbf. Peak at the spine root above the outboard boss, 13.2 ksi
Simulated stress on the aluminum chain guard in a crash slide, bolt side and heel face
Crash slide back, 337 lbf in and 225 lbf back on the pad tip. Peak 23.4 ksi at the spine root
Iterations

Six aluminum versions in a week

Five aluminum chain guard versions side by side: sculpted, Voronoi, branching plate, twin-limb arms and the FEA-resized final
Every version ran the same eight load cases. Renders from the print meshes, masses from the CAD
  1. V7.9

    Plastic rebuild

    Topology optimized PETG and ABS part. Printed, fit checked and on the bike.

  2. V8 to V8.2

    First aluminum

    Same load paths rebuilt as smooth round struts for metal printing, then a sculpted organic pass. Crash cases added.

  3. V9

    Voronoi

    Hollow oval tubes with a Voronoi window pattern. Strong, but 141 g. Too heavy.

  4. V10 and V10.1

    Branching faceplate

    Solid arms back, with a spoke and fork tree in the heel pad. 108 to 110 g.

  5. V11

    Twin-limb arms

    Every long arm split into two branching limbs with cross links. 121 g.

  6. V11.1

    Resized by FEA

    Each limb resized against its own stress. 109 g, all eight cases under yield. This is the one on the bike.

Process

How the metal part was designed

  1. 01

    Keep the load paths

    The plastic part had already found where the material wants to be. The metal version keeps those paths and changes the material and the shape around them.

  2. 02

    Add the crash cases

    A tip-over onto the guard and a slide forward or back are what kill a part in the pits. 450 lbf on the pad tip and 337 lbf plus 225 lbf sideways joined the five riding loads.

  3. 03

    Build shapes from code

    Members, blends, branching rules and the faceplate tree are all parameters. A style change is a rerun, not a remodel. Six styles were screened before one was sized.

  4. 04

    Mesh to FEA, FEA to mesh

    Every build goes straight into a 1 mm voxel FEA. The stress field maps back to the members, and the members resize. Repeat until every case clears.

  5. 05

    Check the print

    Chain gap at the keep-out, support area heel face down, overhang on every limb, and a flat mounting face that bolts to the frame tab with socket access.

  6. 06

    Print, paint, bolt on

    Faceted STEP and a build-orientation STL to the printer. The part came back bead blasted, got painted to match the bike, holes reamed, and bolted on with safety-wired M8s.

Status: the aluminum part is painted and on the bike. Heel-stand proof test numbers and ride results go here as they come in.

Chapter 1: the plastic rebuild

A broken part is the best design brief

The problem

My pit bike runs a printed heel guard that bolts to the frame tab and keeps my boot off the chain. The first one snapped at the arm and cracked at the bolt holes.

The approach

I treated it like a customer failure. Root cause first, then load cases from how the part is really used, keep-outs for the chain, bolts and frame, and topology optimization with an FEA check on every version.

The result

A bridged, open-skeleton guard with a clean mounting face. In simulation it moves 3 to 8 times less toward the chain under the same heel loads, for less than an ounce more.

Root cause

Where it failed and why

The broken original chain guard stub still bolted to the XR50 frame tab
The original guard after it snapped, still bolted to the frame tab
The original printed chain guard installed on the XR50
The original guard on the bike. Its only job is to keep a boot heel off the chain
  • 01A lightening window sat right where the bending load was highest.
  • 02The print layers ran across that load instead of along it.
  • 03The walls around the bolt holes were thin, so they cracked too.
Approach

Real loads in, only the useful material out

Design space for the chain guard with heel loads, chain keep-out and bolt locations
225 lbf heel push, 180 lbf on the edge, scrub both ways and chain slap. Design study render
Design space, topology optimization result and smoothed part side by side
Block of design space, optimized result, smoothed for print. Design study renders
The part

Three features that do the work

Rear quarter render of the final XR50 chain guard
Plastic final: bridged bosses, open skeleton pad, clean mounting face
1

Bridge between the bolts

Both bolt bosses are tied together, so the load spreads across the frame tab instead of tearing at one hole.

2

Open skeleton heel pad

The pad only has to stop a boot heel. A rounded rim and spokes do that with less material, and give the supports a place to land.

3

Clean mounting face

Nothing sits behind the frame side of the part, so it bolts flat to the tab with clear socket access to both bolts.

Iterations

Original to the plastic final

Design evolution from the original guard through three optimized passes to the final design
Every change came from a real problem on the bike
Plastic results (simulated)

Stiffer where it counts

Simulated stress map of the final chain guard at a 225 lbf heel push
Simulated stress at a 225 lbf heel push, linear FEA

Pad movement toward the chain

Load caseOriginalNew
Heel push, 225 lbf0.145 in0.043 in
Heel on outer edge, 180 lbf0.225 in0.028 in
Heel and scrub forward0.085 in0.017 in
Heel and scrub back0.218 in0.053 in
  • About 0.24 in of gap to the chain. The new part stays under 0.06 in in every case.
  • Near-peak stress (99.5th percentile) drops from about 5,900 psi to about 1,600 psi in the worst case.
  • 2.75 oz, up from 1.9 oz. Less than an ounce more for a part that is several times stiffer.

Linear FEA, same loads on both parts. The test print passed the fit check on the bike.

Process

How the plastic part was designed

  1. 01

    Failure review

    Found the cause: a window in the highest bending zone, layers across the load and thin walls at the holes.

  2. 02

    Real loads

    Heel push, heel on the edge, scrub both ways and chain slap for a 180 to 220 lb rider.

  3. 03

    Keep-outs

    Chain in position with clearance, socket access to both bolts and a clean mounting face.

  4. 04

    Topology optimization

    Started from a block of design space and kept only what carries load toward the frame.

  5. 05

    Iterations

    Bridge, rounded pad, open skeleton, clean mount. Each change came from a real problem on the bike.

  6. 06

    Smooth and check

    Smoothed into a printable part and checked with FEA every time it changed.

The test print passed the fit check on the bike and the plastic part runs at the late October moto events. Everything it learned about load paths went straight into the aluminum part above.

Your part

What this means for your project

Parts that keep failing

Root cause first, then a better part.

Send me the broken part or photos of it. I find out why it failed, build load cases from how it is really used, and redesign it so the fix holds up.

Brackets, mounts and fixtures

Lighter, stiffer and built to be made.

Topology optimization and FEA to set the shape, then a design that fits the process, whether that is a plastic print, metal AM, a machined part or sheet metal. You get native CAD, STEP and drawings.

Got a part that keeps breaking?

Send me photos and what it has to do. I review every request myself and reply within 2 business days.

Start a project→